It's been one year since Julie James (the ever-busty Jennifer Love Hewitt) tackled the maniacal hook-handed psycho in the first film. While Julie has gotten her life together enough to go to college, she's still plagued by horrific nightmares about the Gorton's Fisherman. This leads to relationship problems with her boyfriend (the first film's only other returning cast member Freddie Prinze, Jr.).
Julie's best friend (the truly annoying and space alien-looking Brandy - never trust a celebrity with one name) wins a trip to the Bahamas . . . The perfect place for a four teen slaughterama! So Julie, Brandy, Brandy's boyfriend, and a guy with a crush on Julie go to a near-deserted island resort that can only be reached by boat . . .